Tuesday, October 15, 2013

King Philip's War - The History & Legacy of America's Forgotten Conflict



King Philip's War
I found this 26 minute video to be an excellent introduction for younger students to the cause and effect of one of America's most significant and contentious wars. Narrators, well-versed in their subject, and representing a balance of Native American historians and scholars of the American colonial period, including Richard Pickering of Plimoth Plantation, and Eric Schultz and Mike Tougias, authors of the book of the same title,King Philip's War: The History and Legacy of America's Forgotten Conflict describe the inevitability of the war and its horrific consequences for the Wampanoags and the colonists. Admittedly, there are questions left on the table, not unusual for a supplemental classroom aid with time restraints, but, overall, this entertaining video is a good way to stimulate a student dialogue about a subject which is still culturally relevant.

Oddly short bland treatment of one of America's forgotten wars
I was quite excited to find this title- especially considering the involvement of Eric Schultz (author of the 416-page book "King Philip's War"). But this film is really too short to provide a cohesive story, clear context, or interesting depth. "King Philip's War" is perhaps a little dry to capture students' imaginations. Although there are some good clear maps, the film is mostly "talking heads"- there are not nearly enough reenactments, and many historically innaccurate depictions of Wampanoag and nearby Indians. The film also has very amature production (camera quality, effects, resolution)- comes on DVD-R format, and is overpriced at $65 for a 25 min film (aimed at educators). The dvd has no chapters or special features. This was a great idea- but was better execited in We Shall Remain, "After the Mayflower."



Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment