Monday, October 21, 2013

The Our Gang Collection, Archive Collection



Our Gang's all-time lamest films
First off-the-bat, these are all 52 remaining Our Gang films, from 1938-1944, NOT 1942 as the description above reads. These 10-minute short films are the worst in Our Gang's history but I'm giving this collection five stars...and I'll tell you why. During the last few shorts during the Hal Roach period, Our Gang films began their downslide, as Spanky & Alfalfa were older and getting hammier in their acting. Once Roach sold the rights to MGM, the series took a nosedive - but they still had some good moments. The best actor from 1938-1940 was Tommy Bond (Butch) who is a more polished, natural actor; also, Sid Kibrick (Woim) is great as Butch's sidekick, even though his dialogue is limited to lines like, "yeah, Butch." But Spanky and Alfalfa became the worst "Our Gang" actors the older they got; Darla has moments of lameness too, but not to the extreme of Spank & Alf. Buckwheat was OK but was worse in the Gang's final years, 1942-1944. Porky left early, followed by Butch, Alfalfa, Darla...

The Whole Exceeds the Sum of the Parts
This five-disc set presents, with superb sound and visual quality, the final six years of the Our Gang series. Hal Roach started the Our Gang comedies back in 1922 and produced seven years of silent comedy shorts followed by another nine years of talking episodes, the latter of which are well-known to baby boomers from their television syndication as "The Little Rascals." In 1938 Roach sold the production rights for the Gang to MGM, which had already been distributing the Roach films to theaters since the late 1920's. The post-Roach shorts have always been presented as starring "Our Gang," and are the ones featured in this set. They too have been shown on syndicated television and various VHS/DVD compilations over the years, and have shown up occasionally on Turner Classic Movies, but this is the first complete set of what Our Gang experts call "The MGM's" or "The Final 52."

The films in this package are presented chronologically, which means that the first disc is by...

A/V Quality Is Superb Compared To . . .
Great audio and video quality add life to these often-tepidly written and awkwardly "acted" shorts. Sure, there's no "School's Out," "Bored of Education," or "Glove Taps" in the MGM shorts, but a lot of them have that B-movie WWII style of MGM humor that still hits the mark. The earlier Roach comedies were of a different era, a different palette of colors to paint from, but if it's a nostalgic romp down Our Gang Lane you seek, or at least a window into American short subjects from the late 30's and early '40s, this is an essential collection. Wish that the other collections of the earlier shorts had this type of crisp DVD quality.

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment