Only a partial success.
Hello,
First of all, the quality of the picture and sound of these short films is astonishing. Most of these look like they were filmed yesterday.
I am almost finished playing through these DVDs for the first time. The first two discs are mostly very interesting, especially the shorts which don't only consist of an orchestra from the early 1930's standing in front of the camera and simply playing. These quickly get boring.
I also enjoyed disc 4, and really found disc 5 and 6 enjoyable with their very vivid Technicolor footage. Of course most of the discs are really very silly indeed, but if you just go with it, they are a lot of fun.
Then we arrive at disc 3. This consists of a series of short after short, which show clips of various early silent films with an extremely mocking commentary. After the first one, I found the disc almost unwatchable and would certainly never play it again. People who buy this set love the history...
Just great
Fantastic collection of Vitaphone shorts from Warner Archives. The Technicolor examples are quite stunning though the subject matter varies in quality. There is something for everyone in this collection. B&W shorts "Nine O'Clock Folks" and "Surprise" with rarely seen Vaudeville headliners the Duncan Sisters I also enjoyed very much.The restoration and reproduction quality of both picture and sound is generally excellent for such old and neglected films.
Misnomer
The title "Vitaphone Cavalcade of Musical Comedy" is really a misnomer! This 6-disc set has very few of what I would call MUSICAL comedies... Most of it is actually early Vitaphone shorts - some of them taken from early silent footage (albeit with a musical background from the Vitaphone studios) and a few are not even comedies! The title should have been "Early Vitaphone Shorts, Volume 1"... Nonetheless, I found it enjoyable, and - yes - I'm hoping they will release more of them!
Click to Editorial Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment